Business LendingBureau

Compare lenders

KeyBank vs Columbia Bank

KeyBank vs Columbia Bank on SBA 7(a) loans: 2,664 vs 2,229 approved, median $50,000 vs $50,000, and the startup and charge-off gap.

By , Editor · reviewed and updated · How we research this

Short answer

KeyBank and Columbia Bank both write SBA 7(a) loans of a similar size, but they are not interchangeable: KeyBank's borrowers got the lower median rate, 10.75% against 12.50%; and KeyBank lends to startups far more often (68.0% of its 7(a) loans against 10.7%).

Side by side

KeyBank and Columbia Bank compared on SBA 7(a) loans approved, fiscal years 2023 to 2026, using data released September 2026. Computed from SBA 7(a) loan-level FOIA data as of 2026-09-30.
MeasureKeyBankColumbia Bank
7(a) loans approved2,6642,229
Median loan$50,000$50,000
Average loan$323,258$170,858
Median initial rate10.75%12.50%
Median term10 years10 years
Share to startups68.0%10.7%
Charge-off rate (mature cohort)4.7%8.4%
FY2026 loans522682
Change vs FY2025-23%+4%

Loans, median loan, rate and startup share describe recent lending. The charge-off rate is necessarily computed on an older cohort — loans with enough time behind them to have been repaid or failed — so it is not the same set of loans as the rest of the table.

Which one is for you

  • KeyBank is built for small working-capital and equipment requests, and it lends to new businesses more often than not.
  • Columbia Bank is built for small working-capital and equipment requests, and it rarely lends to new businesses.

Match your request to the median, not to the name you recognise. The quietest cause of a file that goes nowhere is approaching a lender whose typical deal is nothing like yours.

Where they overlap

States where both lenders are active, fiscal years 2023 to 2026, using data released September 2026.
StateKeyBank loansColumbia Bank loans
Washington475800
Oregon159772
Colorado19917

A lender being large nationally does not mean it is active where you are. If your state is missing from both columns, neither of these is your answer and the state-by-state view will be more use.

What they both fund

Sectors funded by both, fiscal years 2023 to 2026, using data released September 2026.
SectorKeyBank loansColumbia Bank loans
Construction and contracting319439
Restaurants, bars, and hotels457210
Retail348240
Personal and repair services298211

Read each one in full

Questions people actually ask

Which is cheaper, KeyBank or Columbia Bank?

On the rate borrowers actually received, KeyBank: a median of 10.75% against 12.50% at Columbia Bank, over fiscal years 2023 to 2026, using data released September 2026. Rate is not the whole cost — fees, term and prepayment terms all matter — but this is the middle of what real borrowers got, not an advertised range.

Which is better for a startup, KeyBank or Columbia Bank?

KeyBank, on the record: 68.0% of its SBA 7(a) loans went to businesses the SBA classes as new, against 10.7% at Columbia Bank. Neither figure is a promise about your application, but a lender that almost never writes startup loans is unlikely to start with yours.

What do the charge-off rates of KeyBank and Columbia Bank mean?

4.7% of KeyBank's mature SBA loans were charged off, against 8.4% at Columbia Bank. A higher rate is not misconduct — it usually means the lender takes borrowers others decline, which may be exactly why it would take you. These come from older loan cohorts, not from recent lending.