Compare lenders
BayFirst National Bank vs KeyBank
BayFirst's median SBA loan is $150,000, KeyBank's is $50,000. They are not competing for the same deal — here is which is which.
BayFirst and KeyBank are not really competing for the same loan. BayFirst's median 7(a) loan is $150,000 and KeyBank's is $50,000 — a 3-fold difference. Whichever end of that range your request sits at, one of these two is the wrong door.
Side by side
| Measure | BayFirst | KeyBank |
|---|---|---|
| 7(a) loans approved | 6,974 | 2,664 |
| Median loan | $150,000 | $50,000 |
| Average loan | $158,244 | $323,258 |
| Median initial rate | 12.25% | 10.75% |
| Median term | 10 years | 10 years |
| Share to startups | 1.9% | 68.0% |
| Charge-off rate (mature cohort) | 22.1% | 4.7% |
| FY2026 loans | 16 | 522 |
| Change vs FY2025 | -99% | -23% |
Loans, median loan, rate and startup share describe recent lending. The charge-off rate is necessarily computed on an older cohort — loans with enough time behind them to have been repaid or failed — so it is not the same set of loans as the rest of the table.
Which one is for you
- BayFirst is built for mid-sized requests, roughly $100,000 to $500,000, and it rarely lends to new businesses.
- KeyBank is built for small working-capital and equipment requests, and it lends to new businesses more often than not.
Match your request to the median, not to the name you recognise. The quietest cause of a file that goes nowhere is approaching a lender whose typical deal is nothing like yours.
Where they overlap
| State | BayFirst loans | KeyBank loans |
|---|---|---|
| New York | 666 | 515 |
| Pennsylvania | 210 | 221 |
A lender being large nationally does not mean it is active where you are. If your state is missing from both columns, neither of these is your answer and the state-by-state view will be more use.
What they both fund
| Sector | BayFirst loans | KeyBank loans |
|---|---|---|
| Construction and contracting | 969 | 319 |
| Retail | 889 | 348 |
| Professional and technical services | 999 | 160 |
| Personal and repair services | 612 | 298 |
Read each one in full
Questions people actually ask
Are BayFirst and KeyBank competitors for the same SBA loan?
Mostly no. BayFirst's median SBA 7(a) loan is $150,000 while KeyBank's is $50,000, a 3-fold difference, so they are serving different ends of the market.
Which is cheaper, BayFirst or KeyBank?
On the rate borrowers actually received, KeyBank: a median of 10.75% against 12.25% at BayFirst, over fiscal years 2023 to 2026, using data released September 2026. Rate is not the whole cost — fees, term and prepayment terms all matter — but this is the middle of what real borrowers got, not an advertised range.
Which is better for a startup, BayFirst or KeyBank?
KeyBank, on the record: 68.0% of its SBA 7(a) loans went to businesses the SBA classes as new, against 1.9% at BayFirst. Neither figure is a promise about your application, but a lender that almost never writes startup loans is unlikely to start with yours.
What do the charge-off rates of BayFirst and KeyBank mean?
22.1% of BayFirst's mature SBA loans were charged off, against 4.7% at KeyBank. A higher rate is not misconduct — it usually means the lender takes borrowers others decline, which may be exactly why it would take you. These come from older loan cohorts, not from recent lending.