Business LendingBureau

Calculator

Equipment financing vs. paying cash

What financing costs in interest, against what the cash would earn if you kept it - the only comparison that answers this.

By , Editor · reviewed and updated · How we research this

—Extra dollars paid to finance
—What the retained cash could earn
—Financing better or worse by
—Cash left if you pay outright
—

The honest version of this question is not which is cheaper. It is whether the cash you would hand over has somewhere better to be. If it does — inventory that turns, a hire who pays for themselves — then financing at 10% to keep capital earning 18% is straightforward arithmetic. If the cash would otherwise sit in the account, financing is just a cost. The rate you enter for what a dollar earns is doing all the work here, so be honest about it: use what the last comparable investment actually returned, not what you hope the next one will.

Why avoiding the interest is the wrong instinct

Paying cash for equipment feels like the disciplined choice and is often the expensive one. The interest you avoid is visible and the return you give up is not, so the comparison gets made against zero rather than against what the money would otherwise have done.

If capital in your business reliably returns more than the financing costs, financing is the cheaper option and paying cash is the one that costs you money. If it does not, or if you genuinely have no use for the cash, paying outright is straightforwardly better. Everything turns on that one input.

The input that decides it, and how to be honest about it

Use what capital has actually returned in your business, not an aspiration. For most small businesses the defensible figure comes from somewhere concrete: the margin on stock that turns six times a year, the contribution of the last hire, the return on the last piece of equipment. If you cannot point to a number, that is itself the answer - assume the cash would sit idle and pay for the equipment outright.

What is deliberately not in this calculation

  • Tax. Section 179 and bonus depreciation can change this materially, and in which direction depends on your entity, your income and the year. That is a conversation with your accountant, not a slider on a web page.
  • Residual value, which matters for a lease but not for a purchase.
  • Covenants and liens. Equipment financing is usually secured on the equipment itself; a blanket lien over everything else is a different proposition.
  • The buffer question. Running your balance to the floor to avoid interest is how a solvent business meets a bad quarter and ends up taking an advance.